ad

Green light for removal of Wrexham landmark

Published date: 11 August 2010 |
Published by: Matt Sims


 

WORK to remove one of the region’s most famous industrial landmarks could begin in three months.

The Welsh Assembly has overturned on appeal a decision by Wrexham Council to prevent the removal of tonnes of burnt shale at the former Bersham Bank Colliery site in Rhostyllen.

It means the company involved, West Midlands-based Bersham (Glenside) Ltd (BGL), can now begin to clear the site although the firm has said it is keen to preserve historic elements such as original headgear and listed buildings.

BGL technical director Mike Killett said that “all things being equal” work could begin in about three months.

He said the total cost of the project would run into millions of pounds, adding the setting up of rail sidings alone would be considerable.

Welsh historic monuments agency Cadw had asked that the iconic spoil heap be preserved as it was one of the few remaining of its kind.

The 6m tonnes of spoil could be sold on to the construction industry and would take between seven and nine years to remove.

Bersham Colliery closed in 1986, with the loss of 300 jobs.

Brymbo county councillor Paul Rogers said: “It is not surprising there are concerns in the Rhostyllen area about the removal of this landmark and I share the concerns about the potential effects this may have to the amenity of nearby residents and road users.

“I would hope that throughout this process there is due consideration for residents in the surrounding communities.

“It is now more vital than ever that historic elements to the site are preserved and receive adequate investment.”

The scheme would first of all see the removal of waste on the southern part of the site which would then enable tracks to be put down so the remainder of the material could be removed by rail.

The original proposal was amended by BGL before the appeal to include the retention of part of the tip.

BGL has been told it must pay towards the costs of refurbishing the former winding gear house.

The Assembly document, by planning inspector Clive Nield, reads: “It is not disputed that the loss of the tip would harm the setting of the adjacent Bersham Colliery headgear and buildings.

“The headgear is a scheduled ancient monument and Grade II* listed building; the winding gear engine house is a Grade II listed building and the baths/canteen/ offices building is also Grade II listed.

“(BGL) has put forward an amended scheme to retain part of the tip next to those buildings and structures.

“This would continue to provide a suitable setting for general appreciation of the mining heritage features, albeit that the tip itself would be much smaller and not in its original scale and form.

“Cadw has considered this to be an acceptable compromise.”

It adds: “In assessing the wider visual effects, one must also remember that most
of the tip has been deposited during the 20th century and appears as an alien feature in the original landscape of relatively flat agricultural land.

“In this respect its removal might be seen to improve rather than detract from the older historic landscape.”

Concerns regarding potential noise and air pollution are addressed satisfactorily in BGL’s environmental statement, Mr Nield’s report adds.

Speaking about concerns about potential noise, air or dust pollution, Mr Killett said: “With the working plan that has got to be developed we will be looking at establishing controls and procedures to control noise abatement, dust control and we will be monitoring the noise and dust emissions and take every reasonable step to keep control of dust.”

You must be a registered user to leave a comment. Register or login here.

  1. Posted by: llocally at 08:51 on 11 August 2010 Report

    So, after giving us the Hafod tip and all the 'joys' that brought with it, they are intent on continuing to pillage the Wrexham countryside. After being told no by Wrexham Council, they went crying to SWAG who appear to have no concept of what Glenside are doing to North Wales. Just when will they stop? And when they're done there, there will be a nice little site for development too. Way to go SWAG

  2. Posted by: Common sense at 09:51 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Lets not get all romantic about a pile of waste from mining.it is a landmark but not a nice one.i can't think of a better way of recycling waste,an extra 6 million tons of miners hard work will now be used,once it has gone,we will be able to see the tower and winding rooms in their restored glory.

  3. Posted by: tommy at 12:21 on 11 August 2010 Report

    what's the use of commenting on here if the comments are removed for no reason.Obviously glenside didn't like my last comments,but if there was no truth in my comments why dont the cowboys come on here and defend themselves as opposed to just censoring what i said.

  4. Posted by: yachydda at 16:31 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Well it seems tommy you were abusive... and thanks for removing my post Martin (Ed)... I will not divulge where my information came from... yet.. and I fail to see the libelous comment... regards.

  5. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 16:35 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Sounds like an advert for Bersham Glenside. The picture does not do this landmark justice,it has been taken from the worst angle possible. Where was Cllr Mark Pritchard when it came to making comments? He is the local cllr. From where I am sitting Bersham bank looks beautiful, the flora and fauna on site prove that it has returned to nature. Are they going to kill the newts, buzzards, birds and the like on site for the sake of it?

  6. Posted by: yachydda at 16:37 on 11 August 2010 Report

    WoofyandFluffy: Money is more important than wildlife dont you know !

  7. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 16:42 on 11 August 2010 Report

    The trees on site contribute to reducing CO2 so why not leave it for us all to enjoy. The National Trust has already sold Rhostyllen down the river with its proposed development. Our residents have suffered flooding from our already overloaded drainage system, our gas system failed, electricity failed and all this is BEFORE they rip more out of our greenspaces away.

  8. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 16:48 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Oh I realise that Yachydda! I think it was the Cree Indians who said: Only after the last tree has been cut down, Only after the last fish has been caught, Then and only then will it be realised, That money cannot be eaten. How very true, I will get off my soapbox now!

  9. Posted by: liberty1 at 21:02 on 11 August 2010 Report

    This legacy of a bygone age should have been removed years ago,it represents an era were men new no better and pulled their forelocks when "their betters walked by",it is from the dark ages ,times have moved on,some sadly have not, some are trying to take us back to those days,but enough about the Yack let us dwell on Bersham Bank.

  10. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 21:10 on 11 August 2010 Report

    It is still nice to walk your dog on and take your kids to look at the wildlife. My family have spent many hours "trespassing" on the bank and it has inspired my son to be a happy lad with an appreciation of wildlife. Politically Lib, none of us would be here but for the labours of our downtrodden forefathers. It will be a sad loss of solitude and fresh air for many.

  11. Posted by: liberty1 at 21:42 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Nice to see Yack/Woof have become treehuggers ,I can just see them now in a Tepee at Glastonbury passing the peacepipe,these slagheaps are all over Britian,if you really want to see big ones go to Lancs/Yorks,there is no romance in them, times move on,not always for the good but if it brings some work we must take it.

  12. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 21:55 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Short term work for people who they bring in. The bank is still burning inside, my friend dug the testholes for BG. If you think Im a tree hugger then perhaps I am. Most South/West Yorks tips have not gone back to nature in the way Bersham has. Politics and stereotypes dont come into it for most logical,proud,family people who hate to see things that their kids and grandkids love be destroyed Lib, Its a sanctuary for nature locally. Hope you understand.

  13. Posted by: yachydda at 22:00 on 11 August 2010 Report

    May be Liberty1 you have spent too long in towns and citys... you should get out more you know... and Im proud to value nature... not destroy it.

  14. Posted by: Common sense at 22:09 on 11 August 2010 Report

    I think the only kids and grandkids who like the tip are the ones who have a ball riding motorbikes on it.and i wouldnt say nature has returned on much of it,perhaps the bottom 3rd,the newt argument gets dragged up all the time.and its not being destroyed,its being used,and possibly saving somewhere else being dug up for raw materials.we have a beautifull landscape around us,but the tip isn't one of them.

  15. Posted by: Common sense at 22:11 on 11 August 2010 Report

    I think the only kids and grandkids who like the tip are the ones who have a ball riding motorbikes on it.and i wouldnt say nature has returned on much of it,perhaps the bottom 3rd,the newt argument gets dragged up all the time.and its not being destroyed,its being used,and possibly saving somewhere else being dug up for raw materials.we have a beautifull landscape around us,but the tip isn't one of them.

  16. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 22:17 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Well as my son is 11 and my wifes grandkids are 6 and 3, they are not trail bike riders. From what I can see out of my window its green (at this time of year!) on the village sides. They are taking every bit of land from this village, my hometown was the same. Over Developed and with under funded utilitiy schemes which fail due to lack of investment.

  17. Posted by: yachydda at 22:24 on 11 August 2010 Report

    The tip will soon be gone.. and the memories will live on... its the destruction the removal reaps that worries me...the only good to come out of it short term is the employment...and the regeneration..no matter what we say... the deal is already done... i never knew it had newts though.

  18. Posted by: liberty1 at 22:42 on 11 August 2010 Report

    Yack/Woof,or should I say Keats/Wordsworth,its a slagheap ,nothing more nothing less ,yes some people will have memories linked to it and anyone who really knows the place will know what I mean,ie boy/girlfriends lets not hark back to the mining yrs as some golden era ,it wasnt,as those who were there know

  19. Posted by: pandorasmum at 10:59 on 12 August 2010 Report

    I live near the bank and yes there is lots of nature on and around it, sat in my garden at night I even hear birds of prey, and its actually looking quite pretty at the moment from the village! Tommy - I live on a recent development in the village and my house is not cheap sh*te. Us who live on the new developments are human beings believe it or not so yes, I found it offensive. I don’t want it to go any more than you do – so as a village we need to stick together not run each other down.

  20. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 11:31 on 12 August 2010 Report

    Well said Pandoramum, we all need to stick together including us "incomers" on this one. Lib1, how nice of you to compare me to a great poet, many thanks.

  21. Posted by: liberty1 at 11:35 on 12 August 2010 Report

    Woof, I do give credit when it is deserved.

  22. Posted by: Boycs at 11:53 on 12 August 2010 Report

    Its symbolic and really the only decent landmark that passing people may have to identify some character with wrexham. Where are the welsh nationalist morons that usually crawl out from under their rocks to defend any symbol of wales's mining past, for once it would be welcomed.

  23. Posted by: pandorasmum at 12:38 on 12 August 2010 Report

    Thanks Woofy, glad its not just me... I have never felt so outcast as I do in Rhostyllen.... where on earth is the community spirit??!!

  24. Posted by: WoofyandFluffy at 15:18 on 12 August 2010 Report

    Pandorasmum, unless you are 5th generation villager it can be difficult. Scrapman,Luddites are nothing to do with ecology, just the industrial revolution. Lib I would be worried standing in the choir with Scrapman lol.

  25. Posted by: liberty1 at 16:23 on 12 August 2010 Report

    Woof,Crapman thinks he isTarzan ,swings both ways.My wife actually feels sorry for him.

Featured Businesses

View all adverts